11 Alderfield Lane

Melville, NY 11747

2.1

1 review

Rating breakdown

2.5
Unit quality
2.0
Building
1.5
Landlord
Would recommend 0%

Issues Reported

Reported pest issues 100%
Reported heat/hot water issues 100%

Scores are weighted by health and safety factors. Newer reviews count more than older ones. Learn more

Common issues reported

  • Pest issues 100%
  • Heat/hot water issues 100%

Units reviewed (1 unit)

1 bedroom

1 review

2.1

0% recommend

Incredibly Noisy, Unliveable

Verified This tenant verified their residency with a lease or similar document
2.1 overall
Unit: 2.5 Building: 2.0 Landlord: 1.5

1 bedroom

Winter 2026 · 2023

1–3 years ago

- You won't be able to stay sane living here for longer than a month. Look for any other place, even if it costs more. - The floors are poorly constructed and amplify sounds from above. A family of five will live above you and the kids' parents won't do anything about their kids running around. The landlord lied or skirted around this when he had people touring the place. - Everyday you can expect sounds from a combination of the landlord's kids running around, dog barking, floor creaking, chairs scraping along the floor, yelling - Expect to deal with crickets and spiders regularly throughout most of the year besides winter - The current landlord increased rent after immediately taking over the building. - Internet is slow and unreliable at best. - If you want to end your lease, prepare to have your privacy disrupted constantly - No washer/dryer - Sink leaking issues - Broken refrigerator

1 bed 1 bath

Unit Condition

2.5
Structure * 3/5
Plumbing * 3/5
Electrical 2/5
Climate control * 3/5
Ventilation 3/5
Pest control * 1/5
Mold and moisture * 3/5
Appliances 3/5
Layout 1/5
As advertised 3/5

Building

2.0
Common areas 2/5
Security * 2/5
Exterior 3/5
Neighbor noise 1/5
External noise 3/5
Mail and packages 1/5
Laundry Not rated
Parking 2/5
Trash 2/5

Landlord

1.5
Maintenance 2/5
Communication 1/5
Professionalism 1/5
Lease clarity 2/5
Privacy respect 1/5
Deposit handling 3/5
Rent practices 1/5
Non-retaliation 1/5

* Health and safety weighted. These factors count more in the overall score. Learn more

Security Deposit

3/5

Mixed experience with deposit

Laundry: None Parking: None
Issues reported: Pest issues: Other Heat and hot water issues
Would not recommend Email verified Verified This tenant verified their residency with a lease or similar document

These reviews are written by tenants who lived in the building. We check reviews against our guidelines but can't verify every detail. Terms of service